Talk:Xingcai

as far as I know Koei's Xing Cai is not an interpretation of Liu Shan's two wives, but is only based on his first wife Empress Zhang Xingcai (that's why she's names 'Xing Cai' in DW.....)

Zantam03 21:50, September 1, 2009 (UTC)
 * Well, to my understanding, Zhang Fei historically had at least two daughters. Empress Zhang was the eldest and the one who got married off to Liu Shan. There are no historical documentations of her full name so to say that her full name is Zhang Xingcai would be inappropriate. The only time I saw "Empress Zhang (Xing Cai)" was at here and that's basically a parody that actually reads "Empress Zhang (Changoko)". However, Empress Zhang was the only daughter of Zhang Fei that married Liu Shan that I know of, so maybe it would be better to just say that she's loosely based on Empress Zhang instead of both daughters. Sake neko 22:05, September 1, 2009 (UTC)

sake neko,xing cai is a fake ass girl!if u don't believe me go 2 en.wikipedia.org and type in xing cai.she's a fictional character and so is guan ping.y'all need 2 start checkin' facts.like my favorite singer janet jackson said don't believe everything u here.da stuff that is in here isn't true.the wikipedia tells the truth(except about what they said about Cleopatra,she's black,not white).
 * ... If you read Sake neko's response carefully, it says it's wrong to call her Empress Zhang Xing Cai. The only time Sake neko's seen the name is on a fan parody page. The response was not saying Xing Cai was real. At most it says Xing Cai was based on a real person. Secondly, Guan Ping was real. You're thinking of Guan Suo. He's the fictional son. Third, not everything written on Wikipedia can be trusted. Kyosei 23:51, September 27, 2009 (UTC)

Zhang Fei had two daughters, both married Liu Shan. The eldest daughter, who also became Liu Shan's first wife, has been given a name by Koei (because there are no historical records found of her real name), this name is Zhang Xingcai, or Xing Cai. This name and pretty much everything else she did (aside from marrying Liu Shan) is fictional.

Guan Ping did exist, historically however, he was Guan Yu's real son and not adopted like in Koei games and ROTK.

Zantam03 17:42, October 10, 2009 (UTC)

Too bad she was not on Dynasty Warriors 6...... WhiteStar 19:26 18/12/2010

DW7 has confirmed that Xing Cai is the younger of the two sisters (as in, she's the correct answer to the question "Who married the same person as her older sister?"). She's not the one known as Jing'ai.
 * Actually she would still be known as Jing'ai even if she were the younger sister. Jing'ai means "Empress"; it's not a personal name. Historically, both the younger sister and elder sister are called the same exact name. And there isn't much more you can say about the younger sister aside from what is already there... I think it's just a safe bet just to leave both of them there. :/ Sake neko 17:00, April 22, 2011 (UTC)