Guandu

The Battle of Guandu (官渡の戦い, rōmaji: Kanto no Tatakai) is a decisive battle between Cao Cao's forces and Yuan Shao's forces. Armed with fewer troops, Cao Cao is determined to win against Yuan Shao's massive army. Depending on the title, a secondary follow up to the battle may take place at Runan.

The battle was famous for Cao Cao's assault on Yuan Shao's supply depot, going by the name of Wuchao (烏巣, rōmaji: Usō, lit. Crow Nest), and there by managing to deprive Yuan Shao's army of their resources despite the early pressure Cao Cao was forced under. This eventually brought chaos to Yuan Shao's army and forced him to retreat under great stress.

Guan Yu during this time was under temporary service of Cao Cao's army, and in the Romance of the Three Kingdoms novel was famous for defeating both Yan Liang and Wen Chou in succession, two of Yuan Shao's most fearsome generals at the time. However, it's often stated that Guan Yu and Liu Bei (who was under Yuan Shao at the time) eventually met on the battlefield and escaped together soon after, leaving Cao Cao and Yuan Shao to their devices.

Dynasty Warriors
In Dynasty Warriors 2, with Cao Cao stationed in Guan Du Castle in the southeast and Yuan Shao's own fortress across from his in the southwest (with Yuan Shang's forces as the latter's vanguard), players on Cao Cao's side must keep Yuan Shao's army out of the castle. The northern units are often in frequent danger due to the high morale of both Yan Liang and Wen Chou which in due time would allow them to break through Yan Jin (延津, Enshin; lit. Yan Harbor) and Bai Ma Castle (白馬城, lit. Hakubajō; lit. White Horse Castle). If Yuan Shao manages to reach Cao Cao's castle, he storms the western front with an arrow unit barrage to put further pressure on him. In DW2 specifically however, Yan Liang (and eventually Wen Chou if the former is slain) will converge on Bai Ma in the northeast, while Yan Jin in the northwest has already been occupied by Yuan Shao's army via Wen Chou's proxy.

Though after some time, it's possible to attack the center of the map to invade the Wu Chao Supply Base (which has only a single gate of entry as a singular hairpin-road leading to a dead-end laced with provision silos) guarded by Chunyu Qiong, which can massively turn the tide of the battle. After the Wu Chao depot burns, Cao Cao will issue an all-out charge (and Zhang He defects to Cao Cao's forces). While both Liu Bei and Zhang Fei are involved in the battle, they rarely ever move from their position in the northwest. However, if the Wu Chao depot is taken out, Yuan Shang's army leading the aforementioned siege on Guan Du Castle is unfettered by this as his own morale is very high and will still likely break through most of Cao Cao's defensive line if he is not dealt with soon enough.

In Yuan Shao's scenario however, the battle seems easier albeit one must still remember to not neglect Wu Chao's defense on higher difficulties as around 15 minutes in, Jia Xu will lead a unit that burns Wu Chao automatically and as a result, devastates Yuan Shao's morale and also causes Zhang He's defection.

In Dynasty Warriors 3, Guan Du Castle is instead stationed at the southwest with Yuan Shao across a curving river in the far northwest, with both Yan Jin and Bai Ma Castle absent. Wu Chao itself is now instead randomly set in 1 of 4 bases on the map which forces the player to attempt to find it (with a special cutscene occurring if the player does indeed find it). If Guan Yu makes contact with Yan Liang, he will easily cut him down, then the same will happen for Wen Chou (but both Guan Yu and Liu Bei's forces will retreat if they contact each other on the battlefield). Uniquely for Guan Yu, he has green sergeants defending him, but no other troops. Sooner or later however, Yuan Shao's forces will deploy an arrow tower siege unit in front of Guan Du Castle's only entrance area in the east, and then afterwards later on after some time will break down the castle walls in the north. After the Wu Chao depot burns upon slaying Chunyu Qiong, Cao Cao will issue an all-out charge (but the burning will not occur if any other unit defeats Chunyu Qiong).

In Dynasty Warriors 3: Xtreme Legends, Yuan Shao, Lu Bu, Diaochan and Dong Zhuo gets this stage. Unlike the other Guan Du, this one takes place during the daytime (even though Dong Zhuo's scene shows that his version takes place at night, he also gets the daytime version) In Yuan Shao's version, he gets a completely different version of the battle that he originally gets in the original game. Yuan Shao begins directly outside of the castle's eastern walls rather than his main camp, and most of Cao Cao's units had taken over his supply depots. Guan Yu is shown to be a full on officer of Cao Cao, and has blue guards defending him instead of green sergeants, and has control over Wei Xu and Song Xian, but he is still a Guest General. Like before, if he and Liu Bei meet, both will retreat. Unlike the other stage, Wen Chou and Yan Liang survive their fates and are instead severely injured rather than outright killed. The castle walls are still pulled down, but it is Zhang He who does this, and appears with other units.

If Yuan Shao enters the castle where Cao Cao is located after wiping out a majority of the castle's officers, he will disappear into one of Yuan Shao's supply depots, which is all guarded by Xiahou Yuan, Xiahou Dun, Xu Huang (who appears to ambush Wen Chou), and Xu Zhu. Cao Cao will hide in a random one, and once found, he is to be defeated. He is interestingly guarded by purple colored guards with swords rather than blue.

In Dong Zhuo's version, Cao Cao is the one attacking Dong Zhuo at Guan Du rather than defending it. Dong Zhuo is not inside of the castle, and is instead in the southeastern portion of the map, hidden. If you play as Dong Zhuo, all of his sub officers are revealed, and the supply depots open, though, they do not open for the enemy, who still goes inside of the castle to find him. If one fails to defend the castle, and the enemy heads to the area Cao Cao usually stands, they will find no one is there, and head toward the southeastern depot almost immediately. Weirdly, although cutscenes show the battle is clearly at night, it re-uses Yuan Shao's version and is portrayed in daylight.

In Dynasty Warriors 4, it is similar to the other renditions of the battle: Cao Cao's forces are defending Bai Ma Castle and Yan Jin akin to the second installment (only north of Guan Du Castle in the south). Initially, Yan Liang and Wen Chou come about to slay Wei Xu and Song Xian with ease (as specifically in this stage on the Wei scenario, both Wei Xu and Song Xian are programmed to have have low maximum HP). Guan Yu on Cao Cao's side will slay Yan Liang and Wen Chou in rapid succession. Liu Bei and Zhang Fei are also on the map, and defeating them both will prevent Guan Yu's withdrawal (as the trio of brothers will both personally retreat upon first hearing of one another's presence on the battlefield, then will actively seek each other out).

However, if both Bai Ma and Yan Jin are taken, then Cao Cao is forced to retreat into Guan Du Castle as Yuan Shao closes in and even orders a battering ram to break down a portion of the castle walls. It is only then that Cheng Yu reports on the existence of the Wu Chao Supply Depot that the player is allowed to enter the base (the area's gates are locked at the start of the battle), and Cao Cao himself personally rides out of the castle's eastern-rear entrance to lead a stealth march on the depot. Yuan Shao panics upon hearing the news if Wu Chao has been successfully breached, and orders a support unit lead by Lu Wei Kuang to try and salvage it (thus, only defeating both Chunyu Qiong and Lu Wei Kuang allows the base to be burnt). Once Wu Chao is burned down, enemy morale will shrink and Zhang He will defect to Cao Cao's forces. In Musou Mode, there is also a chance that Lu Bu will appear in the stage seeking revenge on Cao Cao's Forces if he was left alone at Hu Lao Gate and/or Xia Pi.

In Yuan Shao's scenario however, Guan Yu is rather infamous here as he is in Hyper Mode and has high stats akin to the likes of Lu Bu at Hu Lao Gate (thus it is not recommended to take him on if the player is not sufficiently leveled enough). Even after slaying Yan Liang and Wen Chou, Guan Yu will then systematically hunt down the rest of Yuan Shao's officers relentlessly to try and cut them down one-by-one (starting with Yuan Shang right after the initial duo are slain). If the player heads near Guan Yu during this time, he will actively chase them down throughout the entire map, and his onslaught only stops if Liu Bei and he encounter one another to then retreat and leave both Yuan Shao and Cao Cao to their own battle. However, Cao Cao also attempts to trick the player by causing a Supply Unit carrying a rare item to appear around the southeast of the map, only to be an ambush and no rare item is ever dropped. If Guan Du Castle is reached with the battering ram deployed, Cao Cao's unit will march towards Wu Chao depot alongside Li Dian as his reinforcements, albeit with Chunyu Qiong having low maximum HP which forces the player to try and rush back and defend Wu Chao on time.

An altered version of the stage has Cao Cao's army clash with Lu Bu, Dong Zhuo, and the Yellow Turbans in their respective stories. With Wei employing numerous ploys to their advantage, the player must overcome them while keeping an eye on the main camp simultaneously.

Dynasty Warriors 5 has the battle begin when Cao Cao reinforces the three forts. In Cao Cao's scenario, Cao Cao will go to Bai Ma Castle while Xiahou Dun goes to Yan Jin and Cao Pi stays at Guan Du (the former two forts are paths that lead across a river that separates both Yuan Shao and Cao Cao's forces). In a few minutes, Guan Yu will kill Yan Liang lowering the enemy morale. If the player defeats Liu Bei, who is at the north-eastern side of the map, Guan Yu shall then continue and kill Wen Chou. By this time, Zhen Ji and Cao Pi meet up which causes the latter to entice the former into joining him. Guan Yu withdraws after completing his duties and Yuan Shao opens Wu Chao. By defeating the general inside the supply base, Chunyu Qiong, the raid on the supply base becomes a success. In Yuan Shao's scenario, the only problem the player shall be facing is Guan Yu. If the player defeats the God of War, Guan Du shall be poorly guarded from the outside with Cao Pi guarding the exterior. Siege towers are then sent and in just a few minutes, if successful, Guan Du castle opens the gates and Cao Cao will be waiting. Note that Zhang He and Zhen Ji will defect if the supply compound is burned to the ground.

In Dynasty Warriors Vol. 2, the battle appears in Wei's story. In the first few engagements, scouts will report Yan Liang's suspicious activity near Bai Ma castle. If he gets too close to Bai Ma castle, he will set fire to the altar, and will conquer it immediately. Defeating Yuan Shao or taking all the bases of the area will guarantee a Cao victory. Aside from the rescuable village, there is also a treasure trove guarded by Hideyoshi Toyotomi. In Yuan Shao's side, the only victory condition is to defeat Cao Cao. Similarly to Cao Cao's side of the battle, reports will come in stating suspicious behavior near Wu Chao, and a fire attack will wipe out the supply depot if the enemy attack isn't intercepted. Also, using Zhen Ji and meeting Cao Pi will trigger a special dialogue from the two. There are two treasure troves in the area; One is guarded by Hua Tuo while the other is guarded by Genghis Khan.

The only viewpoints available are from Cao Cao and Lu Bu forces in Dynasty Warriors 6. In Cao Cao's scenario, if either the Yan Jin or Bai Ma forts are taken, and Yuan Shao moves to the center camp from the Wu Chao supply base, Xiahou Dun and Zhang Liao may ambush the supply base and set it on fire. If the fire attack succeeds, Zhang He, Gao Lan, and Xu You will defect from Yuan Shao. If Yan Liang or Wen Chou are defeated, Yuan Shao's morale will decrease dramatically. By protecting the allied central bases, the enemy forces will advance slower towards Cao Cao's main camp as they will travel from the west and east. If Guan Yu defeats Yan Liang, he will declare that he has fulfilled his duty and leave the battlefield.

Lu Bu interrupts the battle with his own force in his scenario. Seeing that there is a bigger threat than each other, Cao Cao and Yuan Shao reconcile and set aside their differences, joining their armies together to deal with Lu Bu.

In Dynasty Warriors 7, the stage layout reverts to the old Dynasty Warriors 5 design in a sense. This battle is available in the Wei and Shu story modes.

In Wei's story, the playable character is Cao Pi. In the first part of the battle, he and Jia Xu carry out their mission by defeating as many sub-generals around the stage as possible before Yuan Shao's main force appears. Cao Pi must defeat four generals to trigger the battle's second half, but it is recommended to defeat as many generals as possible (especially Yan Liang and Wen Chou). Cao Cao uses himself as bait to lure the enemy to him, and Jia Xu executes a pincer attack to eliminate generals in the middle of the stage near Baima, and Yanjin fortresses. Cao Pi must escort Cao Cao to Wei's main camp, and part 1 is complete.

In part 2 of the stage, the plan is to defeat the Wuchao supply depot utilizing a newly defected Xu You to open the gates. The stage begins by using catapults to defeat the siege towers (four of them, for the two catapults). Once that's completed, Jia Xu will accompany Cao Pi along a trail with little enemy resistance. From there the player is given the option of either taking the left path to sneak past the ambush unit, or the center to hit the ambush unit head on. Gao Lan typically leads the ambush unit. The best strategy is to jump down from the left path and defeat the general leading the ambush unit. No matter which path is taken, Cao Pi, Jia Xu, and Xu You will continue on and get to the supply depot gates. Once there, Cao Pi must defeat Zhen Ji and the remaining generals surrounding the supply depot. Xu You will open the gates and troops will burn the supply depot down. Zhang He will appear, but once Cao Pi bests him, his defeat triggers his defection to Wei. After this is done, all that remains for Cao Pi is to defeat the remaining generals on the field near the middle and to the north, and Yuan Shao himself.

In Shu's story, the playable character is Zhao Yun. He joins Liu Bei and Zhang Fei as they reinforce Yuan Shao's army. Zhao Yun must first protect the main camp from being taken over by Wei forces that are coming from the west. Then Yuan Shao order's Liu Bei's army to help the defense of Wuchao on the northeastern side. Once Zhao Yun is close, he encounters Guan Yu, who is working for Wei. Although Guan Yu flees from battle, the very sight of him fighting for Cao Cao enrages Yuan Shao, and the nobleman considers Liu Bei a traitor and turns against him. Zhao Yun must escort Liu Bei to the escape point in the southeast. While at Wuchao, the site is set on fire and Zhao Yun must defeat Zhang He and Xu You. After escaping, he must overcome more ambushes led by Zhang Liao and Cao Pi. When Liu Bei closes in on the escape point, Yuan Shao will appear to slay him. Zhao Yun must defeat the noble. Once he is defeated, the stage is complete.

The second installment version of the map reappears as DLC in Conquest Mode, albeit Wuchao's layout is changed to have far less provision silos that are only kept by a fence within the boundary of the stage. Guandu Castle's central palace is also no longer on an elevated plateau.

In Dynasty Warriors 8 the battle appears once again in both Wei and Shu's story. In Wei's scenario, Guo Jia first advises the generals to defend the areas and withdraw in order to bait out the opposing Yuan forces. When this is done, the Yuan forces are unable to conquer the strong defense and Guan Yu slays both Yan Liang and Wen Chou. Soon Liu Bei is sent to check the situation, but he leaves the battlefield alongside Guan Yu when they see each other. Once Wuchao is destroyed, Cao Cao's forces will be able to breach Yuan Shao's camp and the defeated Zhang He and Zhenji both surrender. Oddly, unlike the other titles, Gao Lan stays loyal to Yuan Shao when Wuchao is set on fire.

In Shu's scenario, Liu Bei, Zhao Yun and Zhang Fei are all serving Yuan Shao, having lost their main base at Xiapi to Cao Cao. They first take the western bases to Baima in order to prepare for the siege, however, Yan Liang is slain by Guan Yu during the siege and the Yuan forces now choose to attack Yanjin from the east. When they attack again, Guan Yu reappears and kills Wen Chou. He encounters his sworn brothers and Zhao Yun and the four will leave the battlefield. Yuan Shao misinterprets this as a betrayal and immediately turns on Liu Bei. As Yuan Shao's reinforcements appear, the four decide to escape by the west. Jia Xu will appear and needs to be defeated before the four can actually escape.

In Xtreme Legends, a new what-if scenario is given to Wei in which Lu Bu's surrender is accepted by Cao Cao and the two attack Yuan Shao together. Yuan Shao will attempt to goad Lu Bu into siding against Cao Cao, but the warrior shrugs off the initial messengers, but will defect if more messengers arrive, or if he's forced to remain on the defensive for too long.

In Yuan Shao's version of the stage, Lu Bu will never defect, and will instead rampage across Yuan Shao's army, defeating officers until he himself is defeated. Defeating Lu Bu will eventually entice the Cao Cao's reserve troops to begin their march. Killing Cao Cao will end the battle in a Yuan victory. The only way for Lu Bu to fight on Yuan Shao's side in this scenario would be for the player to use him there.

In Lu Bu's hypothetical storyline, Lu Bu becomes Yuan Shao's rival in the north after defeating Cao Cao. The battle starts with Lu Bu and Zhang Liao advancing on Baima and Yanjin respectively while Chen Gong leads reinforcements, defeating Zhang He in the process. Once the bases are taken, Lu Bu slays Yan Liang and Wen Chou, taking control of their respective supply routes as a result. The Wei forces led by Xiahou Dun arrive to assist Yuan Shao and attack Lu Bu's main camp. Once they are defeated, the gates to Yuan Shao's stronghold open and defeating him results in victory.

Yuan Shao's version of the stage starts out with all of the supply lines having already been taken. As Yuan Shao's men move in to retake the supply lines, Lu Bu's forces will activate the siege weaponry in the defense, and the officer in charge must be defeated. When all supply lines have been taken, Xiahou Dun will appear in the south to help assist in Yuan Shao's charge. The battle is won when Lu Bu is defeated.

Warriors Orochi
In the first game, Nobunaga launches a surprise attack against Da Ji at Guan Du. The main army of Orochi was drawn away due to Shingen and Kenshin's actions to support Nobunaga.Though undermanned and caught off-guard, the Orochi army's use of sorcery and artillery can hinder the coalition's advance. Players may also have to watch out for Da Qiao's imminent march on the main camp. During the battle, Ling Tong arrives to assist Nobunaga's forces. As a result, Ling Tong joins Nobunaga after the victory. Despite this, Huang Zhong reports that Shingen and Kenshin's forces has been defeated at Nagashino.

In Warriors Orochi 2, Guan Du serves as the final battle for the Wei kingdom. Cao Cao and Nobunaga lead the anti-Orochi forces, and order the western frontline to be secured, though meanwhile Masamune fires his cannons from Guan Du castle. If the frontline is secured, the Wei army will move the battle to the center of the field, while Masamune leaves his castle. Eventually, the other two kingdom rulers of Sun Jian and Liu Bei arrive as reinforcements, and they move to finally defeat the revived Orochi. Completing this stage unlocks Sun Wukong.

In Warriors Orochi 4, this initially serves as a battlefield for Wu. The resistance army is led by Sun Quan's forces, as he seeks to overcome his father who is under Nobunaga's coalition. Sun Jian, reinforced by Sun Ce and Zhou Yu, pressure Sun Quan's strategist Lu Xun but they are able to endure for the reinforcements of the Hōjō army such as Ujiyasu and Lady Hayakawa, they manage to defeat Sun Jian's army. After their defeat, Sun Jian and others joined with Liu Bei, Shingen, Kenshin and Hōjō army, who prepared against Nobunaga.

This also serves as a climactic battle much later in the story,  where after Odin is revealed as the true enemy of this dimension, many of Wei and Jin forces along with Yoshimoto, Motochika and the bracelet wielders such as Cao Pi and Mitsunari, lead a daring raid on the stronghold at Guandu. They encounter Seimei Abe and various other agents of Odin and the demon forces, who are testing the strength of humanity, while spying on Odin such as Jia Chong, Zhong Hui and Kanbei Kuroda. After their victory, Seimei Abe explains his true intention of joining Odin joins the resistance.

In the side story, Kotarō along with Li Dian must rescue Zhang Jiao and the Yellow Turbans from the Demon army.

This stage re-appears in Warriors Orochi 4 Ultimate where Xiahou Dun, Takatora, Gaia, Zhao Yun, Yang Jian and others must help Joan of Arc to defeat Kiyomori's army and accompanying her to the escape point.

Kessen
The battle is briefly mentioned in Kessen II. Cao Cao is suddenly attacked by Yuan Shao, which forces him to split his forces to defend against both Liu Bei at Ru Nan and Yuan Shao at Guan Du. Regardless of whoever claims a victory at Ru Nan, Cao Cao will defeat Yuan Shao and conquer his lands.

Historical Information
The battle of Baima (or Boma) was the first battle between Cao Cao and Yuan Shao. Yuan Shao invaded Yanjin (AKA Yan Ford/Yan Harbor) which was easier to capture, while Cao Cao went to Boma Fort in order to distract Yuan Shao. The latter was a success, and Yuan Shao's forces headed to Boma. The battle was easily won by Cao Cao after Guan Yu killed Yan Liang.

The battle of Yan Harbor was the second battle of the two warlords in which Yuan Shao attempted to recapture Yan Harbor. Cao Cao counterattacked and defeated Yuan Shao's force easily after Wen Chou was killed in a planned ambush. Afterwards, Cao Cao withdrew from his bases to focus on Guandu.

Guandu was the third battle of Cao Cao and Yuan Shao. The battle was one of war machines. The first part of the battle started when Yuan Shao used siege towers against Cao Cao. Arrows rained on Guandu and Cao Cao countered by using shields to defend his men. The second part was Yuan Shao attempting to attack the base underground which was easily countered by Cao Cao, ending in a stalemate.

Cao Cao's forces were low on supplies and attempted to raid Yuan Shao's supplies at Wuchao, which was guarded by Chunyu Qiong. The raid was fast and Chunyu Qiong was defeated and executed. Soon after the supplies on Wuchao were burned and Yuan Shao, at Guandu, was forced to retreat to Liyang.

While it was common opinion that Yuan Shao's attempt at a siege on Guandu Castle was rash, there have been debates about his decisions having a different context in that Yuan Shao took ten years to eliminate Gongsun Zan, along with his recent hold on the northern territories not being as secure. Thus, it could be argued that instead of out of arrogance, Yuan Shao was acting out of haste as time was likely not on his side due to these factors.

Romance of the Three Kingdoms
As tensions flared between both Yuan Shao and Cao Cao, Liu Bei, who had fled to Yuan after losing Xuzhou to Cao Cao's forces, wished for Yuan Shao to launch an expedition to save Emperor Xian from Cao Cao's control. While Tian Feng and Ju Shou were against this as Cao Cao had solidified his position and was anticipating an attack from them, Yuan Shao ignored these words and began preparations for war. Cao Cao subsequently declared war on his friend, but Yuan Shao's advisor, Chen Lin, wrote a declaration filled with crimes committed by Cao Cao.

Beginning the first battle, Yuan Shao's general, Yan Liang, attacked Baima. Slaying Song Xian and Wei Xu in quick manner, Yan dueled Xu Huang and defeated him. In response to Yan Liang's attack, Cheng Yu advised his lord to send out Guan Yu. Cao Cao, however, was reluctant to bring out the general as he could leave immediately after fulfilling his debt, but Cheng insisted that Guan Yu killing Yan Liang would likely result in Yuan Shao killing Liu Bei, leaving Guan without a place to go. Cao agreed to send out Guan Yu, broke past the enemy ranks and slew Yan Liang. Yan Liang's death was met by an scout's report to Yuan Shao, who was only told that a red, bearded man wielding a polearm had killed Yan Liang. While there were suspicions that this was Guan Yu, Liu Bei replied that there were many red men with beards, and that it would only be an assumption to say it was Guan. In response to Yan Liang's death, Wen Chou volunteered to attack Yanjin, with Liu Bei supporting him from the rear.

To deal with Wen Chou's troops, Cao Cao ordered his troops to abandon their supplies to an enemy raid. Wen Chou, who attacked his opponent's supplies, easily took the grain, but was unable to discipline his troops sufficiently. As a result, many of the Yuan troops began fighting amongst themselves for the stolen supplies, and Cao Cao's troops returned to counterattack while their enemies were disorganized. Wen Chou's army crumbled immediately, and he attempted to flee. Zhang Liao and Xu Huang both chased Wen, but were both defeated by him and withdrew. Guan Yu, however, was able to catch up with the enemy general thanks to Red Hare's superior speed, and cut him down from behind. With Yuan Shao's troops finally confirming Guan Yu's service to Cao Cao, Yuan Shao attempted to execute Liu Bei, who responded by volunteering to write a letter to Guan Yu to switch sides. Yuan Shao agreed and spared Liu Bei, whose letter caused Guan Yu to desert Cao's forces. Liu Bei's forces would then desert Yuan Shao, however.

Though without Liu Bei, Yuan Shao was not fazed and besieged Guandu castle. Though he brought out his archer platforms to attack the castle, Cao Cao responded with catapults that destroyed the opposing platforms. Locked in a stalemate, Cao Cao's supplies were dwindling, and he sent an emergency messenger back to request for more supplies to hold out. The messenger was caught, however, and Yuan Shao read the message. While Xu You insisted that this meant that they only needed to stall and wait for the enemy supplies to run out, Guo Tu believed that this was a fake letter inciting Yuan Shao's forces into a fake security. Frustrated by his lord's inability, and Guo Tu's further slandering as Xu and Cao were old friends, Xu You visited Cao Cao's main camp, and requested for the amount of days Cao believed his supplies could last. Initially Cao stated only fifty days, only to progressively decrease the amount the more Xu pressed for details. Eventually, Xu You, having heard enough of Cao Cao's lies, presented him with the messenger's letter, revealing that supplies had run out completely. Xu You then advised Cao to lead his cavalry unit to disguise themselves as Jiang Qi's troops and destroy the enemy's supply compound.

Yuan Shao, who had previously not heeded Ju Shou's advice of reinforcing Wuchao, now faced a dilemma of defending his supplies, which were now burning under Chunyu Qiong's watch. Zhang He immediately wished to lead troops to save Wuchao, but Guo Tu believed that Cao Cao's camp should be lightly defended as troops were sent to Wuchao. Zhang He and Gao Lan were sent to attack the enemy camp but were defeated by the defenders of the camp. With little place left to go, both men surrendered. By the time the sun rose, Yuan Shao's troops had lost all morale with the loss of Wuchao and many generals. Broken by the loss, Yuan Shao fled back to his territory in shame.

After the battle, Cao Cao's troops held a celebratory banquet. During the banquet, Cao Cao brought out a large chest, containing many letters from his side, conniving for potential surrender and mercy from Yuan Shao. Though many advisors and generals demanded to hunt down the writers, Cao Cao ordered that the letters be burned, stating that when the battle dragged on, he couldn't guarantee his own safety, let alone others. This move solidified the loyalties of many that previously could've broken away from him, turning many of retainers into devout followers.

On Yuan Shao's end, his health began worsening by the humiliating loss until the arrival of Yuan Tan, Yuan Xi and Gao Gan, along with their armies. Reorganizing his troops, Yuan Shao was ready for battle once more and would meet Cao Cao for the last time at Cangting, where he would suffer immeasurable losses, which resulted in his death.

Trivia

 * When the player using Yuan Shao manages to locate Wuchao in Dynasty Warriors 3 on Cao Cao's scenario, the cutscene that plays is a humorous alteraction via Yuan Shao merely wondering how his base was even found in the first place.
 * In Dynasty Warriors 4, via Cao Cao's Forces scenario, Cheng Yu when reporting of Wuchao's existence is erronously rendered with a private troop's HP portrait as opposed to using the stragetist general's portrait.
 * On part 2 of Wei's version of the battle in Dynasty Warriors 7, there is a minor glitch in the game that confuses Xu You for Zhu Jun in game tasks.